Showing posts with label museum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label museum. Show all posts

Wednesday, 17 June 2015

Hall of Vertebrate Origins

Following on from my previous post about the Hall of Saurischian Dinosaurs at the American Museum of Natural History in New York, which I visited last year, I now present selected photographs of specimens exhibited in the Hall of Vertebrate Origins. The gallery is situated next door to the Saurischian gallery, hence why it is next on this blog. 

All photos taken by Mo Hassan at the American Museum of Natural History, New York, in June 2015.


Tupuxuara leonardii Kellner, 1994
Thalassodromidae; Pterosauria; Sauropsida; Chordata

One of the first specimens to greet you, if you look up, as you enter the Hall of Vertebrate Origins, is a mounted cast of a Brazilian pterosaur called Tupuxuara (named after a Tupi familiar spirit in Native American mythology). Looking at it superficially, it looks like it has a giant head, a little body, spindly legs, and very long arms. With soft tissue in place, this animal probably looked a bit like a giant toucan or some other tropical bird, with membranous skin between the long finger and the hind limbs to serve as wings, and probably a fuzzy body and a colourful head crest.

This specimen is a cast, AMNH 29080, of a specimen collected in Ceará, Brazil, dating from Cenomanian in the mid-Cretaceous. More on pterosaurs will follow in the next post...


Alligator prenasalis (Loomis, 1904)
Alligatoridae; Crocodilia; Sauropsida; Chordata

The genus Alligator contains two living species: the critically endangered Chinese alligator (A. sinensis) from the Yangtze River, and the well-known American alligator (A. mississippiensis) from the southeastern United States. The genus formerly contained many other species which have now become extinct, proving that alligators were found in a far broader range across the globe in former times. This specimen, AMNH 4994, was collected in South Dakota in 1906, and dates from the Oligocene period, around 35 million years ago. This suggests that South Dakota was then warmer and wetter.


Gavialis browni Mook, 1932
Gavialidae; Crocodilia; Sauropsida; Chordata

This long-snouted skull belongs to a relative of today's gharial (Gavialis gangeticus), an endangered fish-eating crocodilian from the Indian subcontinent. This specimen, AMNH 6279, was collected in 1922 from Pakistan, in the Siwalik Hills. These hills are famed for the fossils of early hominids (apes) like Sivapithecus and the okapi-like antlered giraffe Sivatherium, amongst other fossils. It dates to 5 million years ago, and differs very little from the modern gharial.


Voay robustus (Grandidier & Vaillant, 1872)
Crocodylidae; Crocodilia; Sauropsida; Chordata

The smallest modern crocodile species, the dwarf crocodile (Osteolaemus tetraspis), occurs in west and central Africa, and grows to a maximum of 190 cm (6.2 feet). This is one of its close relatives, Voay robustus, from Madagascar. It lived there until fairly recently, the most recent fossils dating to the Holocene, and may have gone extinct only 2,000 years ago. Unlike Osteolaemus, V. robustus grew to 5 m in length and had short horns on the top of the skull behind the eyes. It has been suggested that the Nile crocodile (Crocodylus niloticus), which currently lives in Madagascar, only colonised the island since the extinction of Voay.

This specimen, AMNH 3102, was collected in 1930 in southwestern Madagascar.


Sebecus icaeorhinus Simpson, 1937
Sebecidae; clade Notosuchia; Sauropsida; Chordata

It is well known that the Ancient Egyptians revered crocodiles. The god Sebek represented the Nile, as well as fertility, and was pictured as having the head of a Nile crocodile. The genus Sebecus honours Sebek. This animal was a large terrestrial carnivore, alive during the Eocene period, some 33-66 million years ago. It is not a crocodilian, unlike modern crocodiles and alligators, but a close offshoot of the ancestors of crocodiles, a member of the Notosuchia. Notosuchians were around from the Cretaceous through to the Miocene, with Sebecus being one of the last surviving genera of the group. They were a very diverse group of reptiles, some being obvious predators, while others became herbivorous.

This specimen, AMNH 3160, is a cast of a specimen collected in Argentina in 1931.


Prestosuchus chiniquensis von Huene, 1942
Prestosuchidae; "Rauisuchia"; Sauropsida; Chordata

Prestosuchus ("hurricane crocodile") was a fearsome predator that lived in Brazil during the Late Triassic (around 210 million years ago), at around the same time that dinosaurs were just beginning to diversify into saurischians and ornithischians. It is classed as a rauisuchian, a paraphyletic group of archosaurs close to crocodylomorphs (crocodilians, thalattosuchians, notosuchians, etc.), with an upright walking gait, unlike the sprawling gait of crocodilians.

This specimen, AMNH 3856, is a cast of a specimen found in Brazil in 1937, the original material housed in Germany.


Rutiodon carolinensis (Emmons, 1856)
Phytosauridae; Phytosauria; Sauropsida; Chordata

Phytosaurs ("plant reptiles", a bizarre moniker that is probably a mistake) looked remarkably like crocodiles, with the nostrils placed close to the base of the snout rather than at the tip. Rutiodon ("wrinkled tooth") was a Late Triassic phytosaur from eastern North America (North Carolina and New Jersey). This specimen, with the specimen number AMNH 1, was found in North Carolina in 1895.


Meiolania platyceps Owen, 1866
Meiolaniidae; "Testudinata"; Sauropsida; Chordata

Meiolania ("small wanderer", to distinguish from the giant monitor lizard, Megalania) was a relative of modern tortoises and turtles. It is not classified in the same order, Testudines, as that order is defined as including the common ancestor of all modern tortoises and turtles, which just about excludes Meiolania. However, as the most recent specimen of this creature dates to only 2,000 years ago, it just narrowly misses out on being defined as a testudine. The genus lived from the Oligocene until the Holocene, with this specimen, AMNH 29076 from Lord Howe Island, Australia, dating to 120,000 years BP. Instead of being able to retract its head either into its shell or alongside it like modern testudines, Meiolania had a large horned head and a spiked tail for defence against predators such as crocodiles, mekosuchines (extinct terrestrial crocodiles), and humans.


Thalassomedon hanningtoni Welles, 1943
Elasmosauridae; Plesiosauria; Sauropsida; Chordata

Thalassomedon ("sea ruler") was a long-necked plesiosaur related to Elasmosaurus. It lived in the mid-Cretaceous of North America, when the central part of the continent was underwater. This specimen is a cast of AMNH 29078 from Colorado.


Scutosaurus karpinskii (Amalitsky, 1922)
Pareiasauridae; Procolophonomorpha; Sauropsida; Chordata

Scutosaurus ("shield reptile") was a pareiasaur, a group of primitive reptiles that lived during the Permian in Russia. The Permian was the period of time directly before the Triassic: the transition between these two periods marked the greatest mass extinction of all time. Pareiasaurs like Scutosaurus were herbivorous, feeding on ferns and cycads and other vegetation. It would probably have been slow moving due to its large size, heavy armour, and short legs, and would have relied on its size when mature, and its armour, to protect itself from such predators as gorgonopsids.

This specimen is AMNH 5148, collected in northwestern Russia in the early twentieth century.


Xiphactinus audax Leidy, 1870
Ichthyodectidae; Ichthyodectiformes; Actinopterygii; Chordata

Xiphactinus ("sword ray") was a large predatory fish from the Cretaceous of central North America, colonising the same seas as Thalassomedon above. It could reach 6 m in length, and was definitely among the top predators of the time, swimming alongside mosasaurs as well as elasmosaurs. This specimen, AMNH 13102, was collected in Kansas.


Diplocaulus magnicornis Cope, 1882
Keraterpetontidae; Nectridea; Amphibia; Chordata

Diplocaulus ("double stalk") was an amphibian from Permian North America. It is well known for its boomerang-shaped head. It is often reconstructed as having a fold of skin connecting these bone wedges to the flanks, but it is argued this would have been pointless in life. It could have reached a metre in length, and is considered to be a primitive amphibian, not too closely related to salamanders. This specimen, AMNH 23175, was collected in Texas in 1895 by Charles Sternberg.


Henodus chelyops Huene, 1936
Henodontidae; Placodontia; Sauropsida; Chordata

The final photo is of Henodus ("one tooth"), a turtle-like reptile from the Late Triassic of Germany. Despite its flat turtle-like shell, and obvious turtlyness, it is a placodont, a group of sauropterygian reptiles closer to plesiosaurs than turtles. Placodonts had crushing dentition to eat molluscs and other shelled creatures. Henodus dwelled in shallow lagoons in what is now Germany.

Saturday, 30 May 2015

American Museum of Natural History: Hall of Saurischian Dinosaurs

I visited New York City last June/July, for the first time. Naturally, one of the first places I visited was the American Museum of Natural History. In the first of hopefully a short series of posts on that museum, I feature the Hall of Saurischian Dinosaurs. Saurischians are one of the two major groups of dinosaurs. The most well known members of this group include Brontosaurus, Tyrannosaurus, and the domestic chicken.

The photos below were taken at the American Museum of Natural History, New York, in June 2014, by Mo Hassan. They are presented in rough phylogenetic order.


Plateosaurus engelhardti von Meyer, 1837
Plateosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Plateosaurus (from the Ancient Greek for"flat lizard") was one of the first dinosaurs. Non-avian dinosaurs (that is, all dinosaurs that are not birds), arose during the Triassic Period and lasted until the end of the Cretaceous Period, a stretch of time lasting around 170 million years. Among the earliest were small theropods (bipedal carnivores) like Coelophysis (see below), and Plateosaurus. It was a prosauropod - early offshoots from the branch that later led to sauropods - the long-necked dinosaurs like Brontosaurus. Plateosaurus has been known since the 1830s, when several bones were found in Germany and later identified as dinosaur bone.

Plateosaurus remains one of the best known dinosaurs as over a hundred individuals are known from many parts of Germany. The individual photographed was named Plateosaurus trossingensis Fraas, 1913, but later synonymised with the type species of the genus, P. engelhardti. Its specimen number is AMNH 6810 and was collected by Friedrich von Huene in 1925 in Trossingen in southwest Germany, and dates from the late Norian stage of the Upper Triassic.


Brontosaurus excelsus Marsh, 1879
Diplodocidae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

You may have heard of Brontosaurus, it's got to be one of the most well known dinosaurs of all time. Except that for over a hundred years, it didn't even exist. Well, only in the sense that it has been known to science by another name. Apatosaurus ("deceptive lizard") and Brontosaurus ("thunder lizard") are both types of sauropod, both living at the same time in the same place. For most of the twentieth century they were assumed to belong to the same species, and as the name Apatosaurus was published first, due to the rules of zoological taxonomy, Brontosaurus became demoted to a synonym of Apatosaurus. A study published this year has determined that Brontosaurus is sufficiently distinct from Apatosaurus, and resurrected the name for three species previously assigned to Apatosaurus. One of these is A. excelsus, now B. excelsus, which the above pictured sauropod was identified as.

The specimen, AMNH 460, is mostly real, with the skull based on Apatosaurus louisae, and tips of tail and limbs from another specimen. It dates from 150 million years ago (Kimmeridgian/Tithonian stages of the Late Jurassic). According to the recent study (Tschopp, Mateus & Benson, 2015), which looked at individual specimens rather than species, AMNH 460 is a close relative of both Apatosaurus species and all three Brontosaurus species, but not a member of either. For now, it remains either Apatosaurus excelsus or Brontosaurus excelsus, until a new genus is erected for it if needs be.



Diplodocus longus Marsh, 1878
Diplodocidae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Everyone who's ever been to the Natural History Museum in London will know about Dippy the Diplodocus. Specifically, Dippy is a cast of CM 84, an almost complete skeleton of Diplodocus carnegii Hatcher, 1901, in the collections of the Carnegie Museum of Natural History in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The eponymous philanthropist Andrew Carnegie commissioned ten casts of CM 84 to museums around the world, including London of course. But D. carnegii was not the first species of Diplodocus to be described. D. longus is the type species, meaning it was the first species to be given the genus name Diplodocus.

This skull is specimen AMNH 969, and was collected in 1903 in Wyoming. It dates from the Kimmeridgian stage of the Late Jurassic.


Coelophysis bauri (Cope, 1887)
Coelophysidae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Like Plateosaurus, Coelophysis ("hollow form") is one of the earliest dinosaurs, and is the best-known early theropod. It lived in Late Triassic North America, dating back to around 200 million years ago. This specimen is a cast of CM 31374, a skull from Carnegie Museum collected in New Mexico.


Dilophosaurus wetherilli Welles, 1954
Dilophosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

If you've seen Jurassic Park (who hasn't?), you'll know Dilophosaurus as the cute, frilled, venom-spitting dinosaur that jumps into Dennis Nedry's car and subsequently kills him. Dilophosaurus ("two crested lizard") in reality was somewhat bigger than the film version, and did not have a frill or the ability to spit venom, as far as we know. It is another early theropod, dating to 193 million years ago in the Sinemurian stage of the Early Jurassic. This skull is a cast of AMNH 27376, found in Arizona in 1942.


Ceratosaurus nasicornis Marsh, 1884
Ceratosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Ceratosaurus ("horned lizard") was a contemporary of Allosaurus from Late Jurassic North America. This skull is a cast of AMNH 27631 from Colorado.


Majungasaurus crenatissimus (Depéret, 1896)
Abelisauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Abelisaurids were a group of large theropods found mainly in the southern supercontinent Gondwana. Representatives of this family have been found in South America (e.g. Carnotaurus), India (e.g. Indosuchus), and Madagascar (e.g. Majungasaurus). They all have short heads and tiny hands and arms, making them look really, really silly. Although Majungasaurus ("lizard from Mahajanga/Majunga") has been known for more than a century, it was only since the late 90s that any good material has come out of Madagascar. Prior to that, some specimens were called Majungatholus atopus, and were thought to be the remains of pachycephalosaurs (bone-headed ornithischians).

This skull is a cast of FMNH PR 2100 collected in Madagascar, dating from the Maastrichtian stage dating to 66-70 million years ago.


Allosaurus fragilis Marsh, 1877
Allosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Allosaurus ("different lizard") is one of the most well-known theropods from the Jurassic Period, and was among the largest from the time too. This remarkably complete specimen, AMNH 5753, represents the first free-standing mount of a theropod anywhere in the world, and is depicted tearing apart a Brontosaurus skeleton. It came from Wyoming and dates from the Kimmeridgian stage of the Late Jurassic.


Ornitholestes hermanni (Osborn, 1903)
Family incertae sedis; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Ornitholestes ("bird thief") was another Morrison Formation theropod, believed to be a coelurosaur (an advanced group of theropods including tyrannosaurs and modern birds). This specimen is a cast of the holotype (first specimen), AMNH 619, discovered in 1900 in Wyoming, again of Kimmeridgian age.



Gorgosaurus libratus Lambe, 1914
Tyrannosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Gorgosaurus ("fierce lizard") is a smaller and slenderer relative of Tyrannosaurus. It has previously been placed in the genus Albertosaurus, but is deemed distinct nowadays. It lived slightly earlier than Tyrannosaurus, in the Campanian stage of the Late Cretaceous. Despite being smaller than its more famous relative, it was still an apex predator.

This specimen is a cast of the skull of AMNH 5664 from Alberta. It was initially named G. sternbergi, after its discoverer, Charles Sternberg, but is now considered to be a young individual of G. libratus.


Tyrannosaurus rex Osborn, 1905
Tyrannosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

T. rex needs no introduction, so you're not getting one. This specimen is AMNH 5027, collected in Montana in 1908.


Struthiomimus altus Lambe, 1902
Ornithomimidae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Struthiomimus ("ostrich mimic") was a very slender dinosaur related to Ornithomimus from Campanian-Maastrichtian North America. This specimen is AMNH 5339, collected in Alberta in 1914, and displays the commonly found "death pose" seen in many theropod specimens, and which is also present in modern theropods, birds. The head and neck curl back to touch the back, in a condition similar to rigor mortis known as opisthotonus ("tension behind").


Mononykus olecranus Perle et al., 1993
Alvarezsauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

One group of dinosaurs that were quite close to the ancestor of modern birds is the alvarezsaurids. Mononykus ("one claw") is one of the best known of this group. In fact, Mononykus (previously known as Mononychus before it was realised that name was already occupied by a butterfly) was considered to actually be a bird, more advanced than Archaeopteryx (see below). Mononykus got its name because of large thumb claw, and it has very reduced forelimbs.

This specimen is a mounted composite cast of two specimens, AMNH 28508 and AMNH 28498, collected at different times from different locations in Mongolia. It dates from the early Maastrichtian of the late Cretaceous (70 million years ago).



Archaeopteryx siemensii Dames, 1897
Archaeopterygidae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Archaeopteryx ("ancient wing") is known from around twelve exquisitely preserved specimens from Solnhofen, in Bavaria (Germany). There are now considered to be two species of Archaeopteryx: the type A. lithographica, and A. siemensii. This is a cast (AMNH 5120) of a specimen of A. siemensii known as the Berlin Specimen, as the original is housed at Humboldt Museum für Naturkunde in Berlin. It is the most complete Archaeopteryx specimen. All Archaeopteryx lived during the Tithonian in the Late Jurassic, 150-148 million years ago.


Hesperornis regalis Marsh, 1872
Hesperornithidae; Hesperornithiformes; Avialae; Chordata

Hesperornis ("western bird") was a toothed grebe-like bird that lived during the Campanian stage of the Late Cretaceous in North America and Russia. This specimen, AMNH 5100, was collected in Kansas by Charles Sternberg in 1907.


Gastornis giganteus (Cope, 1876)
Gastornithidae; Anseriformes; Aves; Chordata

The first true bird in this series of photos, Gastornis ("Gaston [Planté]'s bird") was a not-too-distant relative of ducks, geese, and swans, being a member of the order Anseriformes. Gastornithids lived during the Palaeocene and Eocene epochs, some 56-45 million years ago, hence not too long (broadly speaking) after the non-avian dinosaurs went extinct (66 million years ago). It was always considered to be a savage predator due to the shape of its bill, but recent studies on bone histology indicate it never ate meat. Gastornis giganteus used to be considered distinct enough from Eurasian Gastornis that it was placed in its own genus, Diatryma. This specimen, AMNH 6169, was collected in Wyoming in 1916.


Psilopterus australis (Moreno & Mercerat, 1891)
Phorusrhacidae; Cariamiformes; Aves; Chordata

Psilopterus ("smooth wing") was a type of phorusrhacid, birds colloquially called "terror birds" for their fearsome looking appearance and size. Psilopterus is one of the smaller members of this family though, looking more like a seriema on steroids. This skull is AMNH 9157, from Argentina, dating to the early Miocene epoch (21 million years ago).


Saurornithoides mongoliensis Osborn, 1924
Troodontidae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Saurornithoides ("bird-like lizard") is a troodontid from the Campanian of Mongolia. It was a small-sized big-eyed dinosaur, most likely feathered, and this is the type specimen, AMNH 6516.


Velociraptor mongoliensis Osborn, 1924
Dromaeosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Velociraptor ("fast seizer") is another very well known dinosaur, but is much smaller than most people imagine. Blame Jurassic Park again, the animals represented in the film are closer to Deinonychus (see below) in size. Nonetheless, Velociraptor is well known from some beautifully preserved specimens from Mongolia, again from the Campanian. This skull is also the type specimen, AMNH 6515.


Deinonychus antirrhopus Ostrom, 1969
Dromaeosauridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

Closely related to Velociraptor, Deinonychus ("terrible claw") is known from much earlier strata (Aptian-Albian) in North America. It would have been a more fearsome creature than Velociraptor considering its size, no doubt using its switch-blade "terrible claw" to good effect. This specimen is AMNH 3015, from Montana.


Khaan mckennai Clark, Norell & Barsbold, 2001
Oviraptoridae; Saurischia; Sauropsida; Chordata

The final dinosaur in this parade is a relative of the more well known (only in the popular sense, not from the point of view of specimens) Oviraptor. They were toothless, crested, bird-like dinosaurs. Khaan was a contemporary of Velociraptor and Saurornithoides and was most likely feathered. This specimen is a cast of the original specimen IGM 100/973, housed in Ulaan Bataar, Mongolia,

Saturday, 13 March 2010

Door of Death



As you both kindly requested, enjoy this sketch of me running from the door of death. I appreciate the ghost doesn't look like a ghost, live with it :p

Friday, 12 March 2010

New job

Some of you probably know I've started a new job. I am officially a museum support officer for Bruce Castle Museum. You are forgiven if you've never heard of it, I live less than seven miles from the place and had never visited it before this year.

Bruce Castle has existed in some form or another since the 16th Century, when it used to be known as Lordship House. Before then, there was a building on the site, probably dating back to the 11th Century, but little is known about that. King Henry VIII, the notorious misanthropic Tudor king, regularly visited the Castle. The building has been modified several times: in the 17th Century it was home to the Lord Coleraine family. It is said that the upper floors of the museum are haunted by one of the Lady Coleraines' ghosts.

During the 19th Century, Sir Rowland Hill owned the building, turning it into a boarding school for boys. It was reknowned as a progressive, very liberal, school, as Hill did not believe in corporal punishment, which was rife throughout the country at the time. This trait was apparently admired by many people; notably both Dickens and Darwin were fans of the school. Rowland Hill is most famous for inventing the postage stamp: before the Penny Black was invented, the postage system worked on a pay-upon-receipt basis, which needed reform.

Due to this link with the beginnings of the Royal Mail and the postage system in general, the Museum has a large collection of specimens relating to postal history. One of my many jobs so far has been to catalogue documents on this subject, from philately (that's stamp collecting) to the use of various forms of transport to deliver mail, to the role of the Post Office during the First World War. It's a vast departure from my usual interest in natural history, but it's not too bad; there's much to find interesting. The sheer age of the building, the age of the documents I have been working through, and sometimes just the titles of the works are enough to alleviate any looming tedium. A particularly funny one: "My experiences as a camp postman", published in The Stamp Lover in 1919. It is of course about the role of a postman in a World War I army camp.

The Museum holds not only items related to postal history, but other relics, from Roman and Saxon ruins found on site and elsewhere in the London Borough of Haringey, through to some examples of taxidermy and animal bones (I haven't seen anything apart from the stuffed polecat, rabbit and hedgehog on display... if I see more I will certainly blog about it!), into First and Second World War memorabilia. The nose and part of the body of an unexploded bomb which fell on a house in Wood Green from a German bomber is on display; thankfully it was dismantled. It amazes me, as it must do others, to see what life was like for the British public during the War, as there are exhibits on the daily allowances of food and other household items, showing quite literally just how little was allowed to make wartime rations go a long way. There is even an exhibition about Tottenham Hotspurs, the local football (soccer to you Americans!) team.

No doubt I will return with anecdotes and photos as I work my way through stacks of documents and get to see more of the Museum. Who knows, I might even meet Lady Coleraine... whilst working as a librarian at the Natural History Museum, I was nearly killed by a falling door in a dark, deserted corner of the Museum after most sensible people had gone home... it might sound absurd but I had heard that part was haunted...

Sunday, 5 July 2009

More Rogue Taxidermy

Check out an interesting post on the blog Word Grrls about taxidermy, especially rogue taxidermy, which was partially inspired by my post last year on the subject. If you recall, I described the horrific conditions of some (most, in fact) of the stuffed specimens at the Museum of Archaeology and Natural History at Güzelyurt (Morphou) in North Cyprus. Remember that fox?

Sunday, 31 May 2009

100th post special: Darwinius masillae, or Ida

“Ida”
Darwinius masillae Franzen et al., 2009
Notharctidae; Primates; Mammalia; Chordata


Above photograph:
Cast of the original specimen in Natural History Museum
May 2009


Above illustration:
Pen drawing of the cast
May 2009

As my humble contribution to the Ida carnival, I thought I’d offer two original illustrations and a documentary review, and also a summary about Ida, her provenance, her significance and some other thoughts. You may have heard much of this before, so I apologise in advance.

Ida is the name given to the first, and so far only, specimen of the notharctid primate Darwinius masillae. Obviously, her generic name comes from the man who celebrated his 200th birthday posthumously earlier this year, Mr. Charles Robert Darwin. It is no surprise, then, that the species was formally described this year of all years. The ‘masillae’ epithet is more obscure and less obvious. This relates to its origins: it was found some 25 years ago by an anonymous collector in the Messel pits in Germany. The name is Latinised, but instead of ending in the more usual ‘-ensis’, which normally ends names named after locations (i.e. canadensis, mississippiensis, sinensis), it ends in the genitive ending usually reserved for female people, although is sometimes used for place names (i.e. novaehollandiae, novaeangliae, terraesanctae).

The Messel pits are renowned for their status as a Lagerstätte. Roughly translated as ‘place of storage’, Lagerstätten are known for yielding truly well-preserved fossils. As well as Messel, there is Solnhofen, also in Germany, with perfectly preserved Pterodactylus, Rhamphorhynchus, Compsognathus and Archaeopteryx specimens (Solnhofen scene depicted here). The Burgess Shale of British Columbia, Canada, is another example of a Lagerstätte from much earlier (Cambrian period), and the La Brea tar pits in Los Angeles, California, much more recent (Pleistocene epoch). All share in common a veritable bonanza of fossils not found anywhere else, or in such quantities or of such quality. Messel itself contains beautifully preserved examples of, for example, insects, fish, amphibians, snakes, birds, bats, primitive horses, and of course, primates. The reason for such a high diversity of life forms is the basis behind why Lagerstätten exist. In Messel, a crater formed by geophysical forces from the mantle, deep under the crust. The crater filled with water and became a deep lake mostly devoid of life. This is because the bottom of the lake was still exposed to the same geophysical forces that created the crater in the first place, but this time in the form of gases such as carbon dioxide. From time to time, big ‘burps’ of gas would escape from the vents at the lake bottom, and to some extent the lake margins, releasing large amounts of gases into the lake environment. This is key to explaining how Ida might have died.

Ida (pronounced ‘ee-da’, not ‘eye-da’, as I was saying it for a while!) was female and approximately 9 months old when she died. The evidence for both of these factors comes from the skeleton itself, which is 95% complete: a lack of a baculum (penis bone, or os penis) indicates it is not male; hidden teeth high up in the jaw which have yet to emerge indicate she is not fully grown. The preserved skeleton also reveals a pathology which most likely contributed to her death. The right metacarpals (wrist bones) are fused and form a risen lump. This indicates that the bones broke early in Ida’s life, possibly from a fall from a tree. Although Ida survived long enough for the bones to heal, she would have had a hard life to her conspecifics; her tree-climbing abilities would have been greatly impaired and probably couldn’t have found food in the usual way. This resorted Ida to foraging for fallen fruit, foliage and the occasional invertebrate on the ground. She would have been drawn to the lake for a drink, and may have fallen prey to the toxic gases burping out of the muddy margins. Ida was knocked out by the sudden intake of carbon dioxide, and fell in the lake, indisputably drowning. Her lifeless body found itself in its famous pose as it hit the bed.

I mentioned earlier that Ida is a notharctid primate, but what does that mean exactly? The notharctids are a family of extinct primates, placed in the infraorder Adapiformes. It has remained unclear as to where exactly within the Primates the Adapiformes and hence the Notharctidae belong. Much of the focus of the original description (referenced and linked at the end of this post) and the documentary reviewed shortly was on the phylogenetic placement of Darwinius related to two suborders of Primates: the prosimians (lemurs, lorises and their kin), and the anthropoids (monkeys and apes, including humans, which are apes of course). Neither are true monophyletic groups: the prosimians also include the tarsiers, which are actually on the same ‘branch’ as humans, the haplorhines. The original paper uses the more correct terms Strepsirhini and Haplorhini to indicate the true groupings. It occurs to me that the Adapiformes make up a third group.

On Tuesday 26th May, Britain was hit by a double dose of Ida-goodness. I already knew that the documentary Uncovering Our Earliest Ancestors: The Link was scheduled for 9 pm on BBC1, but the other piece of news was bizarrely unknown to me. The Natural History Museum, the place where I work and have studied and worked for the past few years, was to host the REAL Ida specimen for just a few hours, of course, as luck would not have it, on a day I had chosen to take off for my sister’s birthday, dammit. I probably wouldn’t have had authority to see her anyway, as the event was restricted to the press, certain scientists and celebrities, including the revered Sir David Attenborough, who narrated and wrote the script for that night’s documentary. I’m a humble library shelving assistant, and have few, if any, links to the Palaeontology Department, as yet. I saw this on the lunchtime news, and was feeling an odd mixture of pride for my institution, and jealousy for not being there. Oh I’ve met Sir Dave already, twice in fact, so it’s not that. The news was announced, however, that a cast has been presented to the Museum that will be on display from the following day. So naturally, before I started my shift at work I gave Ida’s body double a visit. Oh my, I was blown away by her beauty, although it was a cast. From seeing her on TV the previous night, I expected her to be twice the size, but as with a lot of celebrities, she looked a lot smaller in person.

So onto my review. An overdramatic introduction (this truly was overdramatic... Jens Franzen was quoted as stating that the findings would be “just like an asteroid hitting the Earth”) led into the story of the fossil’s discovery by Jørn Hurum at a German fossil fair in 2006. The counterpart was not mentioned (the other half of the specimen which shows the imprints of the bones, rather than risen ones). An excited Hurum was shown seeing the fossil for the first time when he was filmed opening the crate containing Ida. Radiographic studies, including x-rays (which can be seen in the original paper), proved that the specimen, unlike Piltdown Man, is not a hoax. A quick overview of the skeletal features follows, focusing on the presence of nails on the digits. Three of the authors of the paper, Holly Smith, Jens Franzen and Philip Gingerich were introduced.

Deciphering the fossil’s age was due to the method of preservation. Before being found by Hurum and purchased by the Oslo Natural History Museum, somebody (conveniently anonymously) covered the front face of the fossil with a clear resin. This is, apparently, only done to fossils found at Messel; therefore Ida’s age could be pinpointed to approximately 47 million years old. Other Messel fossils were shown, including Propalaeotherium and Eurotamandua. These fossils date from the Eocene epoch, the second of the Cenozoic epochs, after the relatively ‘dead’ Palaeocene. This was the time when the first true carnivores (the miacids), horses, bats (like Palaeochiropteryx), whales (like Basilosaurus, but obviously not in Messel) and primates were evolving. No mention is made of why the lake was special in that the specimens were so perfectly preserved, of course due to the anoxic mud containing very little oxygen and thus few aerobic bacteria to break down the body. The black fuzz surrounding Ida’s body was not mentioned apart from stating that it is furry; it is not only fur, but also a bacterial slime, which I mentioned to interested passers by at the Museum.

The skeleton was scrutinised further by the quartet: ecological conclusions were being drawn, such as the relatively short limbs indicated an arboreal (tree-climbing) nature, as well as the fact that Darwinius would have been heavily muscular (try imagining a ripped Ida with huge pecs and abs – quite a laugh). The teeth were examined by Holly Smith, the dental anthropologist on the team. Externally they appear to be ‘all-purpose’, suggesting she would eat a variety of foods, but especially vegetation. This was confirmed by examination of the gut contents by Hurum and Franzen, having found leaves and seeds. A detailed CT scan was carried out in the Senckenberg Museum where Franzen is based, from which they were able to create a 3-D image of Ida’s skeleton. On this note, it is incredible that not a single whole animal reconstruction was shown. It took me half an hour to draw one (see end of this post), and I would’ve done it for free, so it can’t be to do with budget. A CGI reconstruction of more than just bones would’ve been greatly appreciated, if not just by me then by all viewers of the documentary who haven’t seen Darwinius reconstructed. This isn’t Night at the Museum, for crying out loud!

Comparisons were made between Ida and a 6 to 9 year old child (incidentally, this confused a few people I met at the Museum when I was answering casual questions – they had read that Ida was 9 months old, but had heard on the documentary that she was 6 years old, in comparative terms), and we see Ida’s namesake, Hurum’s daughter. There is a neat cut-scene where we see the human Ida playing and the notharctid Ida is superimposed over her, as they are in similar positions.

From this point onwards, the documentary dwells heavily on the phylogenetic placement of Ida in comparison to the prosimians and the anthropoids. My favourite part of the documentary follows: an examination of a slow loris (Nycticebus sp.) to show two of the salient features of most prosimians. Most primates have nails instead of claws (some notable exceptions include the needle-clawed galagos [Euoticus spp.] and the aye-aye [Daubentonia madagascariensis]), but a claw is present on the second digit of the hind foot (the toe next to the big toe). This is variously known as the grooming claw or the toilet claw (I prefer the latter term). It is used, fairly obviously, for grooming. The slow loris has a nice example of a toilet claw. The other feature which prosimians like lorises have is the tooth comb. This is made of the lower incisors and canines squished close together to form a comb-like structure, also used in grooming. The loris’ features are then contrasted with Ida’s, who lacks both the toilet claw and the tooth comb.

This immediately suggests that Ida is NOT a prosimian/strepsirhine. According to the documentary, this automatically places Ida on the anthropoid branch. Just because something does not belong in one category, it does not necessarily mean it has to belong in the other. This way of thinking has been criticised heavily by my fellow bloggers and other scientists, so I won’t add too much to that. Comparisons were then inevitably made to anthropoids, but why start and end with the chimpanzee? Obviously their hands and feet look similar, but doesn’t it make sense to look at an anthropoid with a longer fossil record? Clearly, they were trying to oversell the point that Ida is closer to apes than to lemurs.

In reference to Charles Darwin and his theory of evolution by natural selection, Attenborough can be heard saying that there are “billions of species” on the planet. Barely a million have been described, there’s a long way to a billion, let alone ‘billions’. The dependence on the term ‘missing link’ is clear, so of course the most famous link, Lucy, the Australopithecus afarensis specimen discovered in 1974, was featured. It was a nice opportunity, however, to see how Lucy’s reconstructed pelvis compares with bipedal primates, i.e. humans, and quadrupeds, like the chimpanzee.

The injury to the metacarpals was featured, and it was proposed that Ida’s mother may have dropped her. Ida’s death was mentioned in as much detail as I have already gone into. While watching though, I was reminded of how Archaeopteryx lithographica, of which a handful of specimens (such a strange term, how can you have a handful of giant slabs of limestone?) are known, had probably died of the same fate a hundred million years before. This then provoked another thought: other specimens of Darwinius may exist out there, but are lying in “some rich guy’s basement”, to use Hurum’s words. With any luck, Ida’s worldwide media exposure (family in a village in Cyprus have even heard) might motivate private collectors to sell their specimens to museums, obviously for a hugely elevated price which no museum can afford on today’s budgets.

The final nail in the coffin for me in this documentary was the end to the constant search for a trait to link Ida with the anthropoids, and by extension, to us. The authors noticed that the talus bone in the animal’s heel is of a similar shape to those of humans, who walk bipedally. Did it not occur to them that this could be a form of convergent evolution? Just like the opposable thumb and big toe which likens them to chimpanzees, the talus’ shape could have nothing to do with walking upright, or shared ancestry with us. Of course, it may still be true, but not enough analysis has been carried out. In the last minute of the documentary, Ida is declared as “part of our history” and that’s that. End of story. Had this documentary been made much later, as in not yet, the views of other scientists would have made an appearance and made it a much less biased argument. The documentary was, however, drawing upon the points made in the paper itself, which is also full of holes.

You can tell by the length of my review that this was a long documentary, but there was much repetition of ideas. Friends and colleagues with whom I have discussed the programme with have agreed that it could have easily been half as long with still as much detail. Despite this, the documentary is still worth watching, if only for the incredible footage of a sedated slow loris (even slower than usual!) being examined at Duke Lemur Center in Durham, North Carolina.

I leave you with my reconstruction of Ida. I based her on living lemurs and of course on the cast of the skeleton I have illustrated earlier.


Graphite pencil illustration
May 2009

Reference:
Franzen, J. L., P. D. Gingerich, J. Habersetzer, J. H. Hurum; W. von Koenigswald & B. H. Smith (2009). Complete Primate Skeleton from the Middle Eocene of Messel in Germany: Morphology and Paleobiology. In: PLoS One 4(5), 27 pp. (link to PDF here)

Thursday, 27 November 2008

Rogue Taxidermy

I mentioned in the previous post that Guzelyurt Museum of Nature and Archaeology is my least favourite museum of all that I have been to. I admire the fact that northern Cyprus has a museum dedicated to its natural and historical treasures, but I can’t help but feel a little disheartened by the way the specimens look, and the fact that many are misidentified.

Take the following pair of photographs for example: both are of the red fox (Vulpes vulpes), the well known fox from most of the Northern Hemisphere and Australia as well.






One is a specimen from Manchester Museum, and the other from Guzelyurt Museum. The former is a beautifully presented, almost life-like, image of the fox in a relaxed posture with pristine coat and healthy look. The latter, well, what can I say? My mum was giggling when she saw the poor thing in the museum, and my sister Mini commented on the photo on Facebook, saying the thing would give her nightmares. If the specimen was meant to give the visitor an idea of what a living fox looks like, I think Guzelyurt’s atrocities (there were more than one!) would not get that point across.

Many of the scientific names were incorrect: the names for the lapwing (Vanellus vanellus) and the green sandpiper (Tringa ochropus) were swapped around, for example, two species of very similar eagle were swapped round, and the name on the white pelican’s tag was not Pelecanus onocrotalus, the species native to Europe, but P. erythrorhynchus, the American white pelican. The curator must have fancifully thought the white goose in their collection was a rare snow goose (Anser caerulescens), and not the more bog-standard, every-day domestic goose (A. anser). These mistakes may seem trivial, but for those who don’t know what they are looking at, it can mean being led to believe something which is wrong. I don’t know whether the names on many of the stuffed fishes were correct, as I am not skilled in identifying Mediterranean marine fishes, so I put my faith in the Museum’s label for them, as well as the numerous butterflies and other insects pinned in frames.

I do wonder whether I ought to point these errors out to the Museum, or whether they wouldn’t take any notice, and retort that they don’t get many visitors anyway, and those that do walk round in 20 seconds and go upstairs to the much better presented and more complete archaeology section. My parents are going back to Cyprus in a few days, what do you think readers, should I give them a letter to hand to the curator? They don’t appear to have a website and I don’t have their address either.


Something else to give you nightmares:








The best specimens in Guzelyurt Museum were the two-headed and two-bodied lamb, the latter of which I nicknamed "Spider lamb", as it does have eight legs. I don't know how common these deformities are in Cyprus, but if they are rare, surely the Museum should advertise and publicise more.

By the way, the title for this post, “Rogue Taxidermy” comes from the term applied to the taxidermy of mythical creatures or made up animals, such as sewing bits of eagles and lions together to create a griffin! I used the term to refer to Guzelyurt’s practice of the art.

Tuesday, 25 November 2008

My Favourite Museum

My favourite museum is undoubtedly the Natural History Museum, London. Of course I love almost every museum I have been to (the exception being Guzelyurt Museum of Nature and Archaeology; more on that in a future post!), but the NHM stands out for me, as it has been the most prominent institution in my life so far.

It all started for me almost twenty years ago when I was a wee lad of five or six and went to the Museum on a school trip. I don’t remember much of that excursion; however, one event sticks in my mind. A life-size animatronic roaring Tyrannosaurus rex (probably a relative of Traumador’s) shouted at me, and I ran and hid behind the teacher. This picture of me at the Museum with various felids on a subsequent visit is a vision of things to come!






I would visit the Museum every few years or so throughout my childhood and even through my teens. I started to use the General/Zoology library for casual carnivore research when I was about 15 years old, and kept returning until the present.

My affiliation with the Museum became stronger when I started the Masters course there last year. I was given the run of the place, and soon became a volunteer in the Palaeontology department, sorting fossil fish. I am now working in the greatest library in the world as a shelving assistant.

My past has always been associated with the NHM, and I hope my future will be too. The Museum has imparted chunks of wisdom to me and I endeavour to pass on this knowledge to others in years to come.

I hope you enjoyed this post; I was inspired to write it for the Boneyard XXVI, hosted by Traumador the Tyrannosaur at The Tyrannosaur Chronicles this month. If you didn’t arrive here via that blog, go read about the tales of a lovelorn living fossil!

Sunday, 16 November 2008

Jackass & Galapagos Penguins

Here are the penultimate penguins: Jackass penguin (Spheniscus demersus) and Galapagos penguin (S. mendiculus). The Jackass penguin is also known as the black-footed penguin, or the African penguin. Penguins, in Africa? Are you bonkers? What’s next, polar bears in the Sahara? No, don’t be silly. There is a cold-water current responsible for this bird’s distribution, the Benguela Current, bringing nutrient-rich cold water from the Southern Ocean to the south-west Atlantic via South Africa and Namibia.

The Galapagos penguin is the most northerly species of penguin, it is even found at the Equator! This is even more crazy than the idea of an African penguin. Why would a classically cold-climate bird be found in the Tropics? The answer also lies in the ocean currents: cold waters from the Antarctic flow up the Pacific coast of South America towards the Galapagos Islands, bringing nutrients. This current, the so-called Humboldt Current, also gives its name to another species of penguin from the coast of South America, covered in the next post. As a result of warmer air temperatures, the penguins of Galapagos, south Africa and other places are smaller. Other than the little blue penguin of Australia and New Zealand, the four penguins of the genus Spheniscus are the smallest.

Jackass penguin
Spheniscus demersus (Linnaeus, 1758)



Adult Jackass penguin (Spheniscus demersus)

Distribution: southern Africa from 24o38’S to 33o50’S; vagrant to other parts of Africa.

Size: 70 cm (27½”); males and females weigh 2.4-4.2 kg (5 lb 5 oz – 9 lb 9 oz), with males larger than females.

Habitat: breeds on Benguela Current influenced coasts, in burrows with suitable substrate or using bushes and boulders as shelter.

Diet: small fish, cephalopods (such as squid), crustaceans and polychaete worms.

Etymology: Spheniscus = “little wedge” in Greek; demersus = “diving” in Latin.



Immature Jackass penguin (Spheniscus demersus)

Galapagos penguin
Spheniscus mendiculus Sundevall, 1871



Adult Galapagos penguin (Spheniscus mendiculus)

Distribution: restricted to the Galapagos Islands; breeds on Fernandina and Isabela, and maybe on Bartholomew and Santiago Islands; non-breeding range extends to other islands of the archipelago.

Size: 53 cm (21”); the smallest Spheniscus penguin; males weigh 1.7-2.6 kg (3 lb 11 oz – 5 lb 11 oz); females weigh 1.7-2.5 kg (3 lb 11 oz – 5½ lb).

Habitat: low-lying volcanic coastal desert.

Diet: fish (such as mullet and sardine) and crustaceans (such as krill).

Etymology: Spheniscus = as S. demersus; mendiculus = “little beggar” in Latin.



Immature Galapagos penguin (Spheniscus mendiculus)

Oh, and while we're on the topic of Galapagos... if you're in London for the next few months, make sure you visit the new exhibition at the Natural History Museum, Darwin: The Big Idea. There is a stuffed Galapagos penguin there, as well as numerous other animals and plants from the archipelago, and two live animals: Charlie the green iguana (Iguana iguana) and Sumo the Argentine horned frog (Ceratophrys ornata). Not to mention a lot of original material from Charles Robert Darwin's epic voyage that first sparked his theory of evolution by natural selection.